Procedure

Settlement Agreement Offered? 5 Steps for the First 48 Hours

Most people meet their first settlement agreement in a meeting they did not know was coming, and leave it holding a document and a date. The date is usually the thing they think about for the next two days. It is almost the only thing on the table that does not matter very much.

Here is what to do instead, in order.

Hour one: do not agree to anything, including agreeing that you agree

The meeting where a settlement is raised is designed to produce a reaction. Sometimes deliberately, more often just because that is what meetings do. The useful response is narrow: thank them, say you will read it properly, and ask for the offer in writing if it was not already.

What not to do in the room

However reasonable it feels at the time:

• Resign. It changes the legal position fundamentally and it hands away the thing you are being paid for. If you resign, there is usually no dismissal, and a large part of what the settlement was buying evaporates.
• Agree the figure verbally. You have not read the document. The figure is not the deal; the document is the deal.
• Say you are happy with it. It is a natural thing to say to someone who has just been awkward at you for fifteen minutes, and it is quoted back later.
• Sign anything described as “just a formality”. Nothing in this process is a formality.

None of that is adversarial. It is the same answer you would give to any contract handed across a table.

If you are already thinking of leaving

Say nothing about it in the meeting. If the reason you want to go is how you have been treated, resigning is what creates a constructive dismissal claim — and it is also the moment you stop holding anything back. Why the negotiation is almost always stronger before you go than after.

If the word they used was “protected”

“This is a protected conversation” means they are relying on section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996. That protection only covers an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. If discrimination or whistleblowing is in the picture, it may not cover the conversation at all. The gap between the two confidentiality rules.

Hours two to six: read the whole thing

Read it once for shape and once for numbers. On the first pass you are looking for the structure: what is being paid, when, in exchange for what, and what you are agreeing not to do afterwards.

First, work out which document it is

This takes thirty seconds and it changes everything else. A settlement agreement only binds you if six statutory conditions are met, one of which is independent advice. A COT3, reached through an Acas conciliation officer, binds you without any of them — no adviser is required, and none will be provided. And “severance”, “exit package” and “termination agreement” are not legal terms at all. Thirteen words, and which of them mean something.

Then check the arithmetic against your own documents

Errors at this stage are common and they are the easiest thing in the whole process to get corrected, because they are factual rather than negotiable. How the two parts are taxed, and what the rest of the document contains, clause by clause.

The one list to read twice

The waiver — the list of claims you agree not to bring. It is the only clause that decides what you are giving up, and a claim that is not on it may not be settled by it. If discrimination is anywhere in your situation, look specifically for the Equality Act; a document drafted only to the 1996 Act may not reach it. Why that is a second statute, not a detail.

Hour six: work out which clock you are actually on

This is the part people skip, and it is the one that occasionally costs someone their entire position.

The date in the letter is soft

It is a commercial deadline. There is no statute behind it, nothing happens to you if it passes, and an offer that is not accepted simply lapses. The Acas Code of Practice recommends allowing at least 10 days to consider a settlement agreement, and an employer who gives less is the one taking a risk — because too little time can cost them the protection on the conversation.

The date underneath it is hard

Employment tribunal time limits are usually 6 months. They run from the dismissal or the act complained of rather than from anything in the agreement, and negotiating does not pause them. Acas early conciliation is compulsory before a claim and does pause the clock — but only once you have notified Acas.

So the real question is this one

Not “when do I have to sign”, but “how long have I got before the claim I am being paid to give up stops existing”. If those two dates are anywhere near each other, that changes what you do next — and it outranks every other point on this page.

Day one, evening: send one email

Not a negotiation. A holding email that does three things and stops.

What to put in it, and what to leave out

Keep it to five sentences. Each thing in the right-hand column starts a different conversation, and none of them helps you get the extra week.

Why the adviser reason works

It is not about you. A settlement agreement does not stop you bringing a claim unless the six conditions in section 203(3) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 are met, and one of them is that you received advice from a relevant independent adviser. Your employer needs that advice to happen. Asking for enough time to obtain it is asking them to let their own document work.

If you are off sick

Say so, and say what the adjustment is for — time to attend an appointment, or to take the advice in when your condition allows. Acas is explicit that a disabled worker may need longer than the recommended period as a reasonable adjustment. Being signed off does not make an agreement invalid, but it is a good reason not to be rushed. What else changes when you are off sick, including whether your illness counts as a disability in law.

Day two: get it in front of someone who reads these weekly

A straightforward sign-off is an appointment, not a project, and firms that do this work in volume routinely turn it round the same day or the next.

Who pays

Your employer usually contributes to the cost by naming an amount in the agreement — a strong convention rather than a right. The sentence worth saying on the first call is a request to cap the fee at whatever that contribution is. What the contribution normally covers, and the three questions to ask before you instruct.

What to have ready

On a fixed fee, the difference between a call that starts with advice and one that starts with fact-finding is not small.

How to find someone

Any qualified lawyer who is insured for this work and unconnected to your employer satisfies the statute; so can a certified trade union officer or advice centre worker. What matters more than where they are is whether they read these regularly. What the statutory role actually requires, with the local tribunal venue for eight cities.

What you are actually deciding

By the end of the second day you are not deciding whether to sign. You are deciding which of two questions you want answered.

Two questions, two prices

The first is what does this document do to me — the statutory advice on its terms and effect, which is what the employer’s contribution normally pays for. The second is is this figure right — which requires someone to form a view on your claim, is a different piece of work, and is usually charged separately.

Both are legitimate. They cost different amounts and take different lengths of time, and the single most useful thing you can do before you pick up the phone is know which one you are asking for.

If you decide the figure is wrong

Only part of it is negotiable at all. The contractual half — notice, holiday, wages — is whatever the contract and the calendar say, so arguing about it produces a correction rather than an increase. The negotiation is in the compensation, and several of the most valuable items cost the employer nothing: an agreed reference, agreed announcement wording, release of restrictive covenants, a larger fee contribution. What actually moves the figure.

If it is a redundancy

A large part of the offer may be statutory redundancy pay you were owed anyway, and that is not the same thing as compensation. How to take a redundancy offer apart, and how the statutory figure is worked out.

All posts · Calculator · Find a solicitor